In today's competitive business environment, project management has become an essential function that can make or break an organization's success. Over the years, many individuals have become experts in project management and have shared their knowledge with others. However, the demand for skilled project managers has also led to the proliferation of self-proclaimed project management "gurus", but unfortunately, not all of them are genuine experts. In fact, many of these individuals claim to be experts in project management, but they lack the necessary skills and experience to deliver on their promises.

Fake project management gurus often rely on charisma and salesmanship to promote their services. They may claim to have a unique approach to project management or promise quick results, without providing any evidence to support their claims. They may also use buzzwords and jargon to create the illusion of expertise, but they are unable to deliver on their promises.

One of the dangers of fake project management gurus is that they can mislead individuals and organizations into making decisions that can have negative consequences. For example, if an organization follows the advice of a fake guru, it may waste valuable resources on a project that has no chance of success. Additionally, fake gurus may lack the skills to manage complex projects, leading to delays, budget overruns, damaged reputations, and other problems. Gurus can erode trust in the project management profession as a whole. When individuals and organizations are burned by fake gurus, they may become skeptical of all project management experts, including those with legitimate expertise and experience. This can make it more difficult for legitimate project management experts to gain the trust of clients and stakeholders.

‍

So, how can individuals and organizations protect themselves from misleading advice?

Here are ten signs that a project management guru may be a fake:

‍

1. Lack of Industry Recognition

A legitimate project management expert will be recognized in their industry as a thought leader or subject matter expert. They may have written books, given speeches at conferences, or been featured in industry publications. If the guru you are considering lacks this type of recognition, it is a red flag. In project management, recognition within the industry is an essential aspect of being considered an expert. It's not enough to claim expertise in the field; you must have evidence to back up your claim.

Legitimate experts in project management often hold certifications, such as the Project Management Professional (PMP) certification, and have a history of working on successful projects. They may also be members of professional organizations, such as the Project Management Institute (PMI) or the Association for Project Management (APM), which offer rigorous training and testing to ensure that individuals have the necessary skills and knowledge to manage projects effectively. This lack of recognition could mean that the individual lacks the necessary credentials, experience, or track record of success to be considered an expert. Without industry recognition, it's difficult to determine if the individual is qualified to provide project management advice.

‍

2. Overemphasis on "Secrets" and "Shortcuts"

Project management is a well-established field with established best practices and standards. A legitimate project management expert will focus on the basics of project management, such as project planning, risk management, and effective communication. They will not rely on gimmicks or unproven methods.

Fake project management gurus often promote "secret" or "shortcut" methods for achieving success. They may claim to have unique insights that other experts do not have, or they may offer to reveal their "proprietary" methods for project management success.  If this sounds familiar,  it's likely a gimmick designed to sell you services. Project management is a well-established field with established best practices and standards. There are no "secrets" or "shortcuts" that can guarantee project success.

‍

3. Lack of a Proven Track Record

A legitimate project management expert will have a proven track record of managing successful projects. They will be able to provide case studies, references, and testimonials from satisfied clients. They should also have a track record of continuous learning and professional development.

If the guru you are considering cannot provide evidence of their success, they may be a fake. Without a proven track record, it's difficult to determine if the individual is qualified to provide project management advice. Its equally important to consider the recency and industry of their experience. There are a lot of gurus out there peddling dinosaur best practices from twenty to thirty years go.

‍

4. Lack of Focus on Business Outcomes

Personal branding is important for any professional, including project management experts. However, legitimate experts will not overemphasize their personal brand at the expense of their clients' needs. They will focus on providing value to their clients and helping them achieve their project management goals.

Fake project management gurus often overemphasize their personal brand. They may spend more time promoting themselves and their services than providing value to their clients. They may also be more concerned with their own financial gain than their clients' success. A legitimate expert will prioritize their clients' needs and provide value through their expertise and experience.

‍

5. Overemphasis on Tool Knowledge

Project management tools are important for streamlining processes, improving efficiency, and enhancing collaboration among team members. However, they are not the be-all and end-all of project management.

Fake project management gurus may overemphasize their knowledge of tools and technology, without considering the bigger picture of project management. They may claim that their tool or software is the solution to all project management problems, without considering other critical factors such as team dynamics, stakeholder engagement, and risk management.

‍

6. Lack of a Clear Methodology

A clear methodology is essential for project management success. Legitimate project management experts will have a clear approach to project planning, execution, monitoring, and control. They will be able to explain their methodology in a way that is easy for clients to understand.

Fake project management gurus often lack a clear methodology for project management success. They may claim to have a unique approach to project management, but they cannot explain it in a clear and concise manner. Without a clear methodology, it's difficult to determine if the individual is qualified to provide project management advice.

‍

7. Inability to Adapt to Unique Situations

Project management is not a one-size-fits-all approach. Every project is unique and requires a customized approach to ensure success. Legitimate project management experts understand this and are able to adapt their methodology to fit the specific needs of each project.

Fake project management gurus may try to apply a cookie-cutter approach to every project, without taking into account the unique characteristics of each project. They may not be able to provide customized solutions or adapt to changing situations, which can ultimately lead to project failure.

‍

8. Lack of Transparency

A legitimate project management expert will be transparent about their approach, methodology, and pricing. They will be able to provide a detailed breakdown of their fees and services and will be willing to answer any questions you may have.

Fake project management gurus may be less transparent about their approach and pricing. They may use high-pressure sales tactics or make promises that seem too good to be true. They may not be willing to provide a clear breakdown of their fees or may add hidden costs along the way. A lack of transparency can indicate that the individual is more concerned with their own financial gain than with providing value to their clients.

‍

9. Inconsistent or Nonexistent Online Presence

In today's digital age, having a strong online presence is important for any professional. Legitimate project management experts will have an active online presence, including a professional website, social media profiles, and/or a blog where they share their knowledge and expertise.

Fake project management gurus may have an inconsistent or nonexistent online presence. They may not have a professional website or social media profiles, or their profiles may not be updated regularly. This can indicate that they are not committed to their profession or that they may be hiding something.

‍

10. Unrealistic Promises

Project management is a complex discipline that requires experience, knowledge, and skill to execute successfully. Legitimate project management experts understand this and will not make unrealistic promises or guarantees. They will be honest about the potential risks and challenges involved in a project and will work with their clients to develop a realistic plan for success.

Fake project management gurus may make unrealistic promises or guarantees in order to win business. They may claim that they can deliver results quickly, without any hiccups or setbacks. However, project management is inherently risky and unpredictable, and anyone who promises a risk-free project is likely not telling the truth. Legitimate experts will be honest about the potential risks and challenges involved in a project and will work with their clients to develop a realistic plan for success.

‍

The proliferation of fake project management gurus is a cause for concern. These individuals can mislead individuals and organizations into making decisions that can have negative consequences, and erode trust in the project management profession. By being aware of these signs, you can make informed decisions when choosing a project management expert for your organization who can deliver real results.